Dr. Roger Nicole (1915-2010) A Tribute to a Hero
Dr. Roger Nicole, the man I c
onsider primarily responsible for helping me develop my convictions about Christian theology, died yesterday. The previous day he had celebrated his 95th birthday.
Roger R. Nicole was native to Switzerland and long regarded as one of the preeminent theologians in America. He held an M.A. from Sorbonne, an S.T.M. and Th.D. from Gordon Divinity School, a Ph.D. from Harvard University, and a D.D. from Wheaton College. You can read a thorough detailing of this remarkable life of ministry and scholarship on the Gospel Coalition’s website.
I was a student of Dr. Nicole’s at Reformed Theological Seminary in Orlando, Florida from 1991-1993. When I enrolled at RTS I was not a Calvinist. In fact, I was somewhat put off by most people from a Reformed perspective. Even at seminary there were some cocky students who asked questions like “Are you Reformed?” Just the way they asked the question sounded arrogant and snobby. Some of the most obnoxious Christians I had ever met to that point were argumentative Calvinists.
In my first winter short class I was required to take the “Theological Foundations” class taught by Dr. Nicole. There were a number of people like me in the class – Charismatic Protestants who were suspicious of “Reformed” thinking. However, watching Dr. Nicole navigate this dicey territory was a sight to see. He disarmed the hostile Arminians in the room by showing respect for their disagreements and truly understanding their arguments more thoroughly than they did. Conversely, Dr. Nicole understood the weaknesses of his position most clearly and humbly acknowledged them.
It was this demeanor that made me relax and finally start listening to the Seminary’s perspective on theology. In the end, I credit my theological understanding of God’s grace not to the intellect of Roger Nicole, but rather to his character. He was brilliant, spoke multiple languages fluently, and was considered the Dean of Reformed Theology in America by most in the know. But it was his gentle, loving kindness that impressed my wife and me. Even though I didn’t agree with him on a couple of tangent/secondary theological issues, he never made me feel like an idiot because I held a different position. And believe you me, he could have.
My favorite Dr. Nicole story involves another professor of mine, Dr. R.C. Sproul. Once, Dr. Sproul was teaching our Westminster Confession class and lecturing on the subject of “Paedo” or Infant Baptism (a position to which Sproul as a Presbyterian held firmly). In the middle of the class, Dr. Nicole happened to walk through the back of the lecture hall and he and Dr. Sproul exchanged some friendly banter on the subject, as the two held opposing views. When Dr. Nicole exited the room, R.C. looked at our class and remarked, “The fact that he disagrees with me on this subject gives me pause.” Sproul is a genius. However, even he was humbled in the presence of this gentle, theological giant.
Over the years I’ve become much less combative and argumentative, particularly about matters of faith. Central to that ongoing change in my life is the memory of Dr. Roger Nicole’s treatment of people with whom he disagreed. While he could clearly out-think his opponents, his winsome, graciousness made you want to understand what he thought.
I will never be mistaken for a genius, so I won’t waste one second dreaming that someone might ever say I resembled Roger Nicole intellectually. But, in addition to hoping that I get to live until I’m 95-years-old, I pray that my family, friends, parishioners and students would say that they experienced some of Dr. Nicole’s Christ-like kindness through me. Rest in peace, Dr. Nicole. Thanks for your example.
